RetroGeek Toys

Vintage Toys & Geeky Merch

NOTE: This page contains affiliate links. As an eBay Partner and Amazon Affiliate partner, I may be compensated if you make a purchase.

My Little Pony Butterscotch – 40th Anniversary

Butterscotch, part of the 40th Anniversary My Little Pony collection, is a nostalgic nod to the golden days of the franchise. This reissue brings back her timeless charm, inviting fans to celebrate decades of magic and friendship.

Cheerful yellow pony with orange butterfly cutie marks.
Features long, shiny hair for brushing and styling fun.
Comes with a brush, ribbon, and collector poster.
Part of the 40th Anniversary celebration, honoring G1 classics.

Category: My Little Pony Tag: MLP G1 40 Anniversary

$24.99

(Affiliate link)

Description

Description

Butterscotch is a cheerful yellow pony with bright orange butterfly cutie marks that perfectly capture her love for nature and sunny days. Her reissue stays true to the original 1983 design, complete with long, silky hair perfect for styling. Accompanied by her classic accessories, including a brush, ribbon, and collector poster, Butterscotch embodies the joyful spirit of My Little Pony’s earliest years. Her vibrant colors and playful personality make her a delightful addition to any collection.

My Little Pony Butterscotch – 40th Anniversary

Clicking a link to eBay may result in a referral commission being paid if a purchase is made.

My Little Pony G1 Essentials

If you want to learn more about ponies and how to restore them, here are two resources that can help. The first is the unofficial MLP G1 guide (which has photos, prices, etc). The second is my own book, Restoring My Little Pony!

Restoring My Little Pony is the result of almost three years of restoring and customizing My Little Pony toys for my channel RetroGeek Crafts. The book contains 86 pages full of detailed step-by-step guides, project features, material and technique comparisons, and much more. The book is mostly focused on My Little Pony Generation 1 (MLP G1). However, these techniques can be applied to all other generations, including MLP G2, G3, G4, and even G5.

This unofficial MLP guide to the first generation of My Little Pony (known as G1) was created by Summer Hayes. The book provides everything a collector needs to identify G1 ponies and their accessories, and understand their value. The guide contains large, full color photos of every pony, playset and accessory released in the US (and in some cases in other countries) in the 1980s and 1990s.

More My Little Pony Merch and Toys

My Little Pony, launched by Hasbro in 1983, was a beloved toy line featuring colorful ponies with brushable manes and unique symbols, or “cutie marks,” on their flanks. Each pony had its own name and personality, from unicorns to earth ponies and pegasus ponies, inviting kids to immerse themselves in a magical world of friendship and adventure. The toy line was accompanied by animated specials, a TV series, and movies, making My Little Pony a cherished part of 80s and 90s childhoods and a timeless classic for collectors and fans.

My Little Pony G1 Dutch Butterfly Pony (Vintage)

My Little Pony G1 Fancy Pants Baby Bows (Vintage)

My Little Pony Twin Newborns Milkweed & Tumbleweed

My Little Pony G1 Baby Lucky Leaf and Baby Leafy (Vintage)

My Little Pony G1 Cielete Spanish Exclusive Piggy

My Little Pony G1 Birthflower February Violet (Alternate)

My Little Pony G1 Baby Surf Rider (Vintage)

My Little Pony Sweetberry Cranberry Muffins (Vintage)

My Little Pony Vintage Bow Tie (Collectors Pose)

My Little Pony G1 Bow Tie (Collectors Pose UK-Exclusive)

My Little Pony G1 Baby Sparkle North Star (Vintage)

My Little Pony G1 Pretty Ponies Rosy Love (Vintage)

My Little Pony Classics, Celestial Ponies - Polaris

Polaris – My Little Pony Classics, Celestial Ponies

My Little Pony G1 Bridal Beauty (Vintage)

My Little Pony G1 Twinkle Eyed Sweet Stuff (Vintage)

My Little Pony G1 So Soft Lickety-Split (Vintage)

More Vintage 'Girl' Toy Lines

Girl toys from the 80s and 90s hold a special place in the hearts of many, capturing the vibrant and imaginative spirit of those decades. These toys weren’t just about play—they were about storytelling, magic, and adventure. Iconic lines like My Little Pony and Strawberry Shortcake enchanted children with their colorful characters and whimsical worlds, while Rainbow Brite and Care Bears brought magic and friendship to life with plush toys and animated specials. With their vibrant colors, catchy themes, and lovable characters, these toys are more than just relics of the past—they are cherished memories of a time when playtime was filled with endless wonder and creativity.